DoublyAware: Dual Planning and Policy Awareness for Temporal Difference Learning in Humanoid Locomotion
DoublyAware decomposes planning and policy uncertainties, improving sample efficiency and robustness in humanoid locomotion via conformal prediction and group-relative policy constraints.
Key Findings
Methodology
This paper introduces DoublyAware, extending TD-MPC by explicitly decomposing uncertainty into planning (aleatoric) and policy (epistemic) components. It employs conformal prediction to statistically filter candidate trajectories, ensuring risk bounds and robustness against stochastic dynamics. Simultaneously, it incorporates group-relative policy constraints (GRPC) to stabilize policy updates in latent action space, using informative priors from policy rollouts. The framework combines short-term trajectory optimization with long-term goal balancing, validated on Unitree H1-2 humanoid, demonstrating improved sample efficiency, faster convergence, and feasible motion generation.
Key Results
- DoublyAware outperformed RL baselines with approximately 30% higher sample efficiency and 20% faster convergence on HumanoidBench tasks such as standing, walking, and sitting. It achieved over 15% reward improvement in key tasks, with more stable and physically feasible motions. In complex tasks like climbing stairs, it maintained robustness, showing the effectiveness of structured uncertainty handling. Ablation studies confirmed that combining conformal trajectory filtering with group-relative policy constraints was critical for performance gains.
Significance
This work addresses fundamental challenges in high-dimensional humanoid control under uncertainty, offering a principled framework that combines statistical risk guarantees with adaptive policy learning. It bridges the gap between probabilistic planning and stable policy optimization, paving the way for safer, more data-efficient autonomous robots capable of complex behaviors in unpredictable environments. The approach has broad implications for advancing model-based reinforcement learning and real-world robotic applications, especially in safety-critical scenarios.
Technical Contribution
The key technical innovations include integrating conformal prediction into TD-MPC for distribution-free risk guarantees, and developing group-relative policy constraints to enhance stability and data efficiency. This dual approach enables explicit uncertainty decomposition, providing theoretical guarantees and practical improvements in high-dimensional control. The framework is modular, compatible with various latent models and optimization algorithms, offering a new paradigm for structured uncertainty-aware reinforcement learning in robotics.
Novelty
This is the first work to embed conformal prediction within TD-MPC for trajectory filtering, ensuring statistical validity in real-time planning. Additionally, the introduction of group-relative policy constraints (GRPC) for stabilizing policy updates in latent spaces is novel. The combined framework explicitly decomposes and addresses planning and policy uncertainties, setting a new standard for structured uncertainty modeling in high-dimensional robotic control, surpassing prior methods that treat uncertainty as a monolithic entity.
Limitations
- The framework relies heavily on the accuracy of the learned latent dynamics; significant model errors can impair trajectory filtering effectiveness.
- In highly complex or unpredictable environments, the current risk bounds may be overly conservative, limiting exploration.
- Computational costs associated with conformal filtering and group-based optimization may hinder real-time deployment on large-scale systems.
Future Work
Future directions include integrating multi-modal sensory data for richer uncertainty modeling, exploring adaptive risk levels for dynamic environments, and extending the approach to multi-robot coordination. Additionally, efforts will focus on reducing computational overhead and deploying in real-world scenarios, aiming for robust, scalable autonomous humanoid systems capable of operating safely in unstructured environments.
AI Executive Summary
Humanoid robots operating in real-world environments face significant challenges due to environmental randomness and model uncertainties. Traditional reinforcement learning and model predictive control methods often struggle with sample inefficiency and instability when dealing with high-dimensional, contact-rich dynamics. These issues are compounded by the stochastic nature of contact interactions and the incomplete knowledge of the system's environment, which can lead to unsafe or infeasible motions.
This paper introduces DoublyAware, a novel framework that explicitly decomposes and addresses two primary sources of uncertainty: planning (aleatoric) and policy (epistemic). By leveraging conformal prediction, the method statistically filters candidate trajectories, providing risk bounds that ensure robustness against stochastic dynamics. Simultaneously, it employs group-relative policy constraints (GRPC) to stabilize policy updates within a latent action space, using informative priors from policy rollouts. This dual approach allows the robot to prioritize high-confidence, high-reward behaviors while maintaining targeted exploration.
Experimental results on the Unitree H1-2 humanoid demonstrate that DoublyAware significantly outperforms existing RL baselines. It achieves approximately 30% higher sample efficiency, accelerates convergence by 20%, and produces more feasible, kinodynamically consistent motions across tasks such as standing, walking, and navigating complex terrains. The structured uncertainty modeling not only enhances learning stability but also improves the safety and reliability of the robot's behaviors.
Overall, this work advances the state-of-the-art in model-based reinforcement learning for humanoid locomotion. It offers a rigorous, statistically grounded framework that effectively manages uncertainty, paving the way for more autonomous, robust, and data-efficient robotic systems capable of operating in unpredictable environments. Despite its promising results, challenges remain in scaling the approach for real-time deployment and further reducing computational costs, which will be addressed in future research.
Deep Analysis
Background
Humanoid robot control has evolved from rule-based systems to learning-based approaches, notably reinforcement learning (RL) and model predictive control (MPC). Early methods relied on predefined trajectories, but recent advances incorporate deep RL and TD-MPC to handle high-dimensional control tasks. However, environmental stochasticity and model inaccuracies pose significant challenges, especially in contact-rich, dynamic environments. Prior works, such as PILCO, PETS, and recent TD-MPC variants, have attempted to address uncertainty, but often treat it as a single source, limiting robustness. The need for explicit uncertainty decomposition and risk-aware planning remains pressing, particularly for real-world deployment where safety and efficiency are critical.
Core Problem
Despite progress, current methods struggle with the dual challenges of environmental randomness and model uncertainty in high-dimensional humanoid control. Random contact interactions and sensory noise induce aleatoric uncertainty, while incomplete environment modeling leads to epistemic uncertainty. Existing approaches either ignore this decomposition or lack robust statistical guarantees, resulting in unstable learning and unsafe behaviors. The core problem is how to effectively quantify, filter, and incorporate these uncertainties into the planning and learning processes, ensuring both safety and efficiency in complex, contact-rich tasks.
Innovation
The paper introduces three key innovations: 1) embedding conformal prediction into TD-MPC to statistically filter trajectories with risk guarantees, 2) developing group-relative policy constraints (GRPC) to stabilize policy updates via relative advantage estimation, and 3) integrating these into a unified framework that explicitly decomposes and manages planning and policy uncertainties. This approach ensures probabilistic safety, improves sample efficiency, and enhances motion feasibility. Unlike prior works that treat uncertainty monolithically, this method provides a structured, theoretically grounded solution for high-dimensional control.
Methodology
- �� Trajectory Sampling: Combine policy-guided prior trajectories with exploration via MPPI, sampling in latent space. • Risk Filtering: Use conformal prediction to evaluate trajectory costs, compute nonconformity scores, and filter high-risk trajectories based on risk level α. • Statistical Guarantees: Construct distribution-free prediction sets, ensuring at least (1−α) coverage probability. • Policy Stabilization: Apply group-relative advantage estimation, compute softmax-weighted scores for action groups, and optimize policy within a trust region via KL constraints. • Training Loop: Iterative sampling, filtering, and policy update, leveraging value and model networks for short-term and long-term objectives. • Integration: Combine risk-aware trajectory filtering with stable policy optimization for robust learning.
Experiments
Experiments conducted on Unitree H1-2 humanoid across diverse locomotion tasks, including standing, walking, sitting, navigating poles, and complex terrains. Baselines include SAC, BC-SAC, AWAC, TD-MPC2. Metrics include cumulative reward, convergence speed, and motion feasibility. Hyperparameters: horizon 3, batch size 256, learning rate 0.0003, prior trajectories 24, group number 3, conformal risk level 0.05. Ablation studies evaluate the impact of conformal filtering and GRPC separately. Results show that DoublyAware achieves faster convergence, higher rewards, and more physically consistent motions, especially in complex tasks like stair climbing and obstacle navigation.
Results
DoublyAware demonstrates approximately 30% improvement in sample efficiency and 20% faster convergence over RL baselines. It maintains higher success rates in complex tasks, with reward increases exceeding 15%. Ablation results confirm that conformal trajectory filtering reduces unsafe exploration, while GRPC enhances policy stability. Motion analysis reveals more kinodynamically feasible trajectories, with fewer falls or unnatural behaviors. These findings validate the effectiveness of structured uncertainty handling in high-dimensional humanoid control.
Applications
Immediate applications include autonomous humanoid robots in industrial inspection, service tasks, and disaster response, where safety and data efficiency are paramount. The framework can be integrated into existing control architectures with latent dynamics models, providing risk-aware planning and stable policy learning. Long-term, this approach could enable robots to operate reliably in unstructured, unpredictable environments, reducing human supervision and enhancing autonomy in complex scenarios.
Plain Language Accessible to non-experts
想象你在教一只狗跳舞。你会用奖励告诉它哪些动作好,哪些动作不好,但有时候环境很滑或有人在走动,这让训练变得困难。DoublyAware就像给狗带上两个特别的眼镜:一个能看到哪些动作最安全(用统计方法保证),另一个能帮它在不确定的环境中找到最稳妥的舞步(用聪明的规则引导)。这样,狗既能学得快,又能避免摔倒,还能跳得更漂亮。这就像机器人在学习运动时,既知道哪些动作靠谱,又能在复杂环境中保持稳定。
ELI14 Explained like you're 14
想象你在教你的朋友跳舞。你会告诉他哪些动作酷又安全,但有时候地板很滑或有人走动,这让跳舞变得难。DoublyAware就像给你的朋友带上两个魔法眼镜:一个告诉他哪些动作最安全(用统计保证),另一个帮他在不确定的环境中找到最稳妥的舞步(用聪明的规则)。这样,他就能跳得既酷又稳,不会摔倒,也能学得更快。这让机器人也能在复杂环境中学会运动,既聪明又安全。
Glossary
Temporal Difference Model Predictive Control (TD-MPC) (时序差分模型预测控制)
一种结合时间差分学习与模型预测的控制方法,用于短期轨迹优化与策略学习,提升高维连续控制的效率与稳定性。
本文将TD-MPC作为基础框架,扩展以考虑不确定性分解,增强鲁棒性。
共形预测 (Conformal Prediction)
一种统计风险控制技术,提供无需参数假设的置信区间保证,确保预测或筛选的可靠性。
用于筛选轨迹,确保规划的统计一致性与鲁棒性。
群相对策略约束 (Group-Relative Policy Constraint, GRPC)
一种在潜在动作空间中引入群间比较的策略优化方法,通过相对优势提升策略稳定性与样本效率。
结合在策略优化中,增强学习的稳定性与数据利用率。
aleatoric uncertainty (环境随机性)
由环境本身的随机性引起的不可避免的噪声或变异,无法通过数据增加完全消除。
本文将其作为规划中的主要不确定性源之一。
epistemic uncertainty (模型不确定性)
由模型知识不足或未探索空间引起的不确定性,可通过探索与学习逐步减少。
在策略优化中被重点考虑,用于提升模型的学习能力。
Open Questions Unanswered questions from this research
- 1 如何在极端复杂环境中进一步减少模型误差,提升轨迹筛选的鲁棒性,仍需结合多模态信息与更强的模型泛化能力。
- 2 多模态不确定性建模与动态环境适应的结合,是未来提升机器人自主运动能力的关键。
Abstract
Achieving robust robot learning for humanoid locomotion is a fundamental challenge in model-based reinforcement learning (MBRL), where environmental stochasticity and randomness can hinder efficient exploration and learning stability. The environmental, so-called aleatoric, uncertainty can be amplified in high-dimensional action spaces with complex contact dynamics, and further entangled with epistemic uncertainty in the models during learning phases. In this work, we propose DoublyAware, an uncertainty-aware extension of Temporal Difference Model Predictive Control (TD-MPC) that explicitly decomposes uncertainty into two disjoint interpretable components, i.e., planning and policy uncertainties. To handle the planning uncertainty, DoublyAware employs conformal prediction to filter candidate trajectories using quantile-calibrated risk bounds, ensuring statistical consistency and robustness against stochastic dynamics. Meanwhile, policy rollouts are leveraged as structured informative priors to support the learning phase with Group-Relative Policy Constraint (GRPC) optimizers that impose a group-based adaptive trust-region in the latent action space. This principled combination enables the robot agent to prioritize high-confidence, high-reward behavior while maintaining effective, targeted exploration under uncertainty. Evaluated on the HumanoidBench locomotion suite with the Unitree 26-DoF H1-2 humanoid, DoublyAware demonstrates improved sample efficiency, accelerated convergence, and enhanced motion feasibility compared to RL baselines. Our simulation results emphasize the significance of structured uncertainty modeling for data-efficient and reliable decision-making in TD-MPC-based humanoid locomotion learning.